Hall of Fame Progress Resetting/Not Saving

There are a few scenarios that can cause this:

• You uninstalled and then reinstalled the game. If on PC, your new download will be in a separate file with its own Hall of Fame progress. You may be able to retrieve your data by finding the original file in your save directory and moving it to the new folder.
• You got those wins on a different rule set. In the top right corner of the Hall of Fame menu, there should be a drop-down that allows you to select the different game modes/rule sets.
• The game is drawing from new save data instead of your original, or your saved data has been corrupted. If data is only stored locally instead of on the cloud, your original progress is likely no longer available.